Get all the gourmet ingredients and make a scrumptious meal all by yourself. Or go to the nearest fine dining restaurant for a gourmet chef’s tasting menu. What will you choose? It depends on your mood and budget, and rightly so.
However, the dependencies are not so straightforward for organizations seeking a mobile device management (MDM) solution for Android environments (except, of course, the budget part of it, which is universal to most decisions in life).
Choosing the right fit between an open-source MDM and a commercial MDM requires a lot of drawing board actions. For organizations and IT teams, it’s about a thorough need analysis based on the management requirements of their Android device fleets.
This blog will outline the deciding factors and compare open-source and commercial mobile device management (MDM) to determine which is the right fit for organizations.
Open-Source MDM Solutions: An Overview
Open-source MDM solutions are a specific type of open-source software dedicated to managing an organization’s mobile devices, typically Android (or, at times, Linux).
Open source software is characterized by its publicly available source code, which allows developers and users to access, modify, and redistribute it freely. This type of software development thrives on collaboration, enabling a community of developers to enhance the software and introduce new features in response to user feedback.
As a favored alternative to proprietary commercial MDM solutions, open-source MDM solutions provide unique features that differentiate them.
Differentiating Open-Source MDM from Commercial MDM
Features & Capabilities
Thanks to their readily available source code, open-source mobile device management tools offer enhanced flexibility and customization possibilities. This accessibility enables organizations to adapt solutions precisely to meet their unique requirements.
Conversely, commercial MDM solutions typically include a broad range of features and integrations, delivering extensive capabilities for managing devices comprehensively.
Effectiveness & Scalability
Open-source MDM solutions can scale to accommodate organizations of different sizes. Yet, matching the performance and stability of commercial MDM products often demands additional effort and resources.
Conversely, commercial MDM providers commit significant investments in research and development. This ensures their products can manage large device volumes, deliver high performance, and maintain stability even under significant usage.
Support & Service Level Agreements (SLAs)
Open-source mobile device management tools thrive on community involvement, which enhances collaboration and the exchange of knowledge among participants.
As a result, open-source communities can deliver significant expertise and quick response times motivated by common objectives and shared experiences. Conversely, commercial MDM providers often supply specialized customer support and SLAs to guarantee prompt issue resolution and reduce downtime.
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Open Source MDM solutions provide financial benefits due to reduced licensing and subscription fees, attracting organizations that are mindful of their budgets.
Nevertheless, it’s crucial to assess the overall cost of ownership, which encompasses implementation, customization, maintenance, and support expenses. In contrast, commercial MDM solutions might come with higher upfront costs but typically offer more stable and predictable pricing.
Open Source MDM vs. Commercial MDM: A Comparison Table
| Parameter | Open Source MDM | Commercial MDM |
| Cost | Generally free or low cost. Costs may arise from customization, implementation, and support. | Typically requires a subscription fee. Includes support and maintenance costs. |
| Customization | High customization possibilities to tailor specific features to business needs. Requires technical expertise. | Limited customization based on the package purchased. Easier to implement with less technical demand. |
| Security | Varies significantly; dependent on community updates and the organization’s ability to implement and maintain security protocols. | Often includes robust, regularly updated security features compliant with the latest standards. |
| Support | Community-based support, which can vary in responsiveness and expertise. | Professional support teams provided, with guaranteed response times and service level agreements (SLAs). |
| Scalability | Can be highly scalable, but depends on in-house expertise to manage scalability effectively. | Designed to scale easily with minimal technical overhead, suitable for growing businesses. |
| User Interface | Often less user-friendly; may require more technical proficiency to navigate and utilize effectively. | Typically more user-friendly with intuitive interfaces and better user experience. |
| Implementation Time | Can be lengthy due to the need for customization and potential lack of documentation. | Generally quicker to implement due to pre-configured settings and clearer setup guides. |
| Updates and Maintenance | Dependent on the community or in-house teams to develop and apply updates. | Regularly updated by the provider with the latest features and security patches. |
| Compliance | May require additional effort to ensure compliance with regulations like GDPR, HIPAA, etc. | Usually includes built-in compliance features for common regulations, reducing the effort required to meet legal standards. |
| Integration | May require manual integration or development of custom solutions to work with existing systems. | Often includes pre-built integrations with popular enterprise software and systems. |
| Learn how to implement an MDM policy |
Who is Open-Source MDM For?
Open Source MDM solutions offer distinct advantages for organizations with particular needs and functionalities:
Small to Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs): SMBs often operate within tight financial constraints. Open-source mobile device management offers an affordable and adaptable option for managing devices effectively.
Organizations with In-house Development Expertise: Businesses that have experienced development teams can utilize open-source MDM for tailored control over (Android) devices.
Companies with Specific Security or Compliance Needs: Such organizations can take advantage of the transparency and customization options provided by open-source mobile device management to meet their exclusive security or compliance standards.
Drawbacks of Open-Source Mobile Device Management
Inconsistent Support
Open-source mobile device management tools generally depend on community support. This type of assistance can vary widely and often lacks the consistent level of expertise or response time that commercial MDM vendors offer through dedicated customer support teams.
Security Loopholes
Open-source MDM software offers transparency with its publicly accessible source code. However, the responsibility for maintaining security typically rests with the organization using the software. Therefore, devices are under constant threat from bad actors who can inflict severe financial and reputational damage if they sneak into a network or device.
Insufficient Feature Range
Open-source mobile device management solutions provide a varying range of features and integrations compared to commercial options. This may necessitate extra customization or the use of third-party tools to match the functionality of their commercial counterparts.
Implementation Hassles
Setting up and customizing an open-source MDM software often involves greater complexity and requires more time compared to commercial alternatives, especially for organizations that lack technical expertise internally.
Works Only for Open-Source OS
One of the most concerning limitations of open-source MDM is that it can only support open-source operating systems like Android. Sadly, there aren’t many businesses worldwide which solely use Android devices for work. Thus, for organizations with heterogeneous device and OS environments, an open-source MDM can only work for Android, while the likes of Windows, iOS, and macOS would need a commercial MDM solution.
Open-source MDM is Good… But Commercial MD is Better!
There’s no denying that an open-source MDM solution has its own set of benefits. It’s particularly helpful for small business setups with a small device fleet limited to Android. Even then, it would require strong coding skills. Moreover, the drawbacks of open-source MDM far outweigh its benefits. The biggest drawback is a fragile security front that can lead to serious cybersecurity mishaps, which can, at times, wipe out an entire business from its existence.
While a commercial MDM solution like Scalefusion may come with a price tag, the multi-OS capabilities it brings to the IT table are extensive. In addition to the robust security features it offers, it’s safe to say that long-term returns and benefits make up for the upfront investment.
Want to know more about Scalefusion? Schedule a demo with our experts. Start your 14-day free trial now!
